Aired: November 1, 2006 | Season: 2 | Episode: 7

Overview
Runtime: 43m
Directed by: Matt Earl Beesley
Written by: Andrew Wilder
Guest stars: Andrew Rothenberg, David Grant Wright, Dean Cudworth, Jamie McShane, Jason Beghe, Kayla Mae Maloney, Kelly Kruger, Lisa Clifton, Lisa Waltz, Mark Henderson, Mimi Michaels, Todd Jeffries, Tom Schmid
Description
After a man kidnaps three teenaged girls and locks them in a cellar, he tells them only two of them will live and they must choose which one will die. The BAU team takes the case when the mother of one of the girls travels to Quantico to ask JJ to intercede with the FBI on the girls' behalf.